The uncomfortable truth about becoming a Managing Director
There comes a point in an investment banker’s career when being excellent at execution is no longer enough.
You’ve spent years developing your technical expertise, managing complex transactions, working under pressure and establishing yourself as someone senior colleagues can rely on. You may have become the person everyone wants on their transactions. Your MD trusts you, clients respect you and your team depends on you.
Naturally, you start thinking about the next step: becoming a Managing Director. But there is a fundamental difference between being an outstanding investment banking Director and becoming a successful, commercially accountable MD.
At some point, you need to move from executing business to generating it.
For many bankers, that transition is far more uncomfortable than they anticipated — not because they lack intelligence, technical ability or ambition, but because origination requires them to become beginners again in a discipline where rejection and uncertainty are part of the process.
Origination is sales. And sales is a skill.
Let’s call origination what it fundamentally is: sales. Investment banking involves sophisticated advice, technical expertise, industry knowledge and complex relationships. You are not simply selling a product. You are building trust, identifying opportunities and convincing people that you are the right person to advise them on important financial decisions.
Ultimately, you are developing business. And business development is a skill.
Some people are naturally more comfortable approaching strangers or presenting confidently. Others find those situations intimidating. But being extroverted does not automatically make someone an excellent originator, any more than being introverted prevents someone from becoming one.
Successful client relationships are built through credibility, curiosity, consistency, listening, judgement and trust. Those qualities are not exclusive to one personality type.
You don’t have to be naturally good at origination. But you do have to be willing to become good at it.
Why successful bankers struggle with becoming beginners again
You know how to execute a transaction. You can anticipate problems, manage teams and operate under intense pressure. That competence has become part of your professional identity.
Now imagine initiating a conversation with a potential client who has no particular reason to speak with you. You may not know what to say. You might worry about sounding inexperienced. Perhaps the person does not respond, or the meeting goes nowhere.
For someone accustomed to being highly capable, those experiences can be deeply uncomfortable. It is tempting to retreat into the work where you already feel competent. There is always another transaction to execute, another presentation to prepare or another urgent request.
Execution offers a clearer sense of control. Origination does not. You can prepare thoroughly, have an excellent conversation and still achieve nothing commercially. You can spend months developing a relationship that never produces a transaction. You can do everything reasonably well and still lose the mandate.
That is not necessarily evidence that you are failing. It is part of learning how to develop business.
You cannot want to win Wimbledon while refusing to compete
Before working in investment banking, I was a professional tennis player. That experience shaped how I think about ambition, performance and the willingness to tolerate discomfort.
Imagine an exceptionally talented tennis player saying: “I have the ability to become the best player in the world. But I don’t want to compete in front of thousands of people. I don’t want to feel nervous, risk losing or deal with the pressure of being judged.”
You cannot separate the ambition of becoming a world-class athlete from the demands of competition. Playing under pressure is not an unfortunate inconvenience alongside the profession. It is part of the profession.
You can practise for years and perform brilliantly in training. But eventually, you have to walk onto the court. You have to compete. You have to risk losing.
I see a similar dynamic among ambitious investment bankers. They want the MD title, seniority, compensation and recognition, but hesitate when it comes to the activities that make someone commercially successful. They hope that if they continue executing exceptionally well, someone else will create the commercial opportunity for them.
You cannot expect to become comfortable doing something you have consistently avoided doing.
Your MD is not going to build your client relationships for you
A common assumption among ambitious VPs and Directors is that their Managing Director will gradually introduce them to clients, involve them in pitches and help them establish independent coverage.
Sometimes that happens. There are excellent MDs who develop the next generation of bankers, share opportunities and invest in their teams. But relying entirely on that happening is risky.
Your MD has their own revenue targets, client relationships and commercial responsibilities. They may value you enormously as the person who ensures transactions are executed successfully. They may even want you to progress. But that does not mean they will create your commercial career for you.
In some teams, established MDs control client relationships, sector coverage and revenue attribution. Sharing commercial independence can mean sharing opportunities, economics or influence.
Take ownership of your commercial development without disregarding client ownership or competing recklessly with colleagues. Seek exposure, contribute to relationships and build credibility over time. The earlier you begin, the better.
Client relationships are not built when you suddenly need revenue
One of the biggest mistakes bankers make is treating origination as something to focus on once they become Directors or approach promotion to MD. By then, they may already be behind.
Strong relationships take time, consistency and repeated interactions. You need to understand how a client’s business works, what their priorities are, what challenges they face and how their thinking evolves.
Trust cannot simply be manufactured when you suddenly need a mandate. Nor should every interaction have an immediate commercial objective. If every conversation feels like an attempt to sell something, building genuine trust becomes harder.
The objective is to develop relationships in which your knowledge, judgement and understanding become valuable to the other person. The work begins long before the transaction.
The uncomfortable work you have to be prepared to do
You may have to contact someone who does not know you. Ask for a meeting without knowing whether they will agree. Attend an event where you feel out of place. Introduce yourself to more senior people. Follow up after receiving no response. Make a pitch that does not result in a mandate.
You may feel awkward, embarrassed or as though you do not belong. Those feelings are real, but they are not necessarily signals that you should stop.
The mistake is interpreting discomfort as evidence that you are not suited to the task. In professional sport, nobody expects to become exceptional without repeatedly practising what they are not yet good at.
The objective is not to eliminate rejection. It is to become increasingly capable of handling it.
Execution is the foundation. It is not the destination.
None of this means execution stops mattering. Clients need technical expertise, sound judgement and the ability to deliver. They will not continue trusting you if you cannot execute what you have promised.
But at senior levels, execution is increasingly an expectation rather than your primary point of differentiation.
Why should a client choose you? Why should they call you when considering an acquisition, disposal, financing or strategic decision? Why should they trust your judgement over that of another experienced banker?
Those questions cannot be answered through technical excellence alone. They require relationships and commercial judgement. Investment banking is a relationship business. Transactions are the visible output; relationships often create the opportunity.
How to develop origination skills before becoming an MD
1. Stop waiting until you feel ready. There will always be another technical skill to master or another transaction to complete. Start before you feel completely confident. Confidence is often the result of experience, not a prerequisite.
2. Study the best originators. Observe how successful MDs initiate conversations, ask questions, maintain relationships between transactions and earn trust. Learn the behaviours behind their success without trying to imitate their personalities.
3. Take ownership of existing client interactions. Understand the client’s wider strategic priorities, offer relevant perspectives and seek opportunities to participate beyond immediate execution. Become known for your judgement.
4. Make relationship-building a regular responsibility. If business development happens only when execution is quiet, it may never happen. Make deliberate time for relevant conversations, sector relationships and thoughtful follow-up.
5. Practise initiating conversations. You do not need an elaborate pitch every time. Sometimes the objective is simply to begin a relationship, learn something useful or establish a reason to stay in touch.
6. Learn from rejection. Not every meeting will go well. Ask whether your approach was relevant, whether you listened and how you could communicate your value more clearly.
7. Create space by delegating execution. Maintaining high standards does not mean personally controlling every detail. As you grow, allow others to take ownership so you have room for commercial responsibilities.
What if you discover you actually enjoy it?
What initially feels intimidating can become one of the most rewarding parts of the profession. You grow more confident initiating conversations, recognising opportunities and building genuine relationships with people whose businesses interest you.
Eventually, clients may start calling you. Instead of waiting for transactions through someone else’s relationships, you begin creating opportunities yourself.
For someone who enjoys competition, relationships and commercial responsibility, that can be enormously energising. But you may never discover it if you refuse the uncomfortable learning process.
Do you actually want to become an MD?
Do you genuinely want the commercial responsibilities that come with becoming a Managing Director? Or do you primarily want the title, compensation and recognition?
In a client-facing, revenue-generating investment banking role, MD typically means greater accountability for relationships, business development and commercial performance. The pressure does not disappear with promotion. It changes.
There are valuable banking careers built around execution, technical expertise and specialist responsibilities. Not every successful banker needs to pursue the same path.
But if your ambition is to become a commercially successful, client-facing MD, you need to understand what the role requires — and be willing to develop those capabilities.
You don’t have to love origination from the beginning. But you cannot build a career around avoiding it.
Final thoughts
The transition from execution to origination is not simply a change in responsibilities. It is a change in mindset.
You move from being rewarded primarily for delivering work exceptionally well to helping create that work. You become comfortable with uncertainty, rejection and situations where technical expertise alone is not enough.
As a former professional athlete, I know discomfort and pressure are not necessarily obstacles to success. Very often, they are part of the process that makes success possible.
You do not have to be naturally good at origination. But you have to be willing to become good at it.